Struggling to keep up with Charles I, Cromwell and Charles II's antics? Well no need to worry any more as you're in the right place! Here you will find useful notes and simple information to help you succeed in your A2 History (course 3D British Monarchy: The Crisis of State) exam in May! My name is Caitlin Hughes, I received A* at History A-level and currently on a gap year.

Showing posts with label regicide. Show all posts
Showing posts with label regicide. Show all posts

Thursday, 11 September 2014

To Kill a King - an Act of Regicide

The trial of Charles I began on January 20th 1649 in Westminster Hall. The public were allowed access to the trial. 135 commissioners were appointed as judges and John Bradshaw, an inexperienced judge, was President of the Court. 
After Pride's Purge, it was difficult to assemble a Court to judge Charles as many stayed away from Westminster and many did not want to be associated with the trial of the Kind. Fairfax, although a leader of the NMA, only attended one meeting on the trial of Charles. When his name was called to register attendance at the trial, there was silence - his wife, who was in one of the public galleries, shouted "he hath more wit then to be here."
Only 68 out of the 135 commissioners attended the trial - with only 59 signing the death warrant. 
  • This suggests how radical the commissioners must have thought the event was. Also, there was also the possibility of one of Charles' sons or a member of the royal family becoming monarch again and the people who had allowed the execution of Charles would be hunted down, tried and executed themselves for treason. 
Charles was tried for crimes against his people and the laws of England. It was claimed that Charles had attacked the fundamental constitution of the Kingdom and also banned the people from their traditional right to government. 
Charles complained about these charges, due to the fact that the legality of the trial was in question. The Rump Parliament was different as it was biased and did not support the King, plus the fact that it had not been elected. Charles questioned their right to judge him as they were not a legitimate authority and they had no right to put the King to trial. 

January 30th - Charles' public execution 

Before his death, Charles' last speech declared that he had fought for the liberties of the people and declared himself a "martyr of the people."
After Charles' execution, some reports suggest that there was a stunned silence at the moment of execution. One 17 year old boy in the crowd at Whitehall recorded that the execution was met with "such a groan as I have never heard before, and desire I may never hear again." Similar views were repeated as one man claimed no king "ever left the world with more sorrow: women miscarried; men fell into melancholy."

Was the Trial of Charles I always meant to end in Execution?

Yes 
  • Many believe that Charles was responsible for two wars and this was his justice. He needed to be removed so there would be no more Royalists uprisings.
  • The NMA's success during the Civil Wars was seen as "God's providence" (God's doing) he was meant to be punished. Coward states that religious zeal pushed Cromwell to execute Charles.
  • The intransigent settlement negotiations had gone on for too long. Coward saw Charles as "blocking future peace" and "had to executed"
  • Pride's Purge appears to be calculated - Charles was going to suffer a punishment 
  • Kishlanksy states that in the weeks before the trial began "there was no turning back."
No
  • Settlement period was hugely unsuccessful due to Charles. Some saw the impending trial as a way to force Charles into settlement, not to remove him. Many MPs felt pressured into appearing as commissioners - execution was not the only option 
  • Starkey - the death warrant of Charles suggests there was indecision over the event. Starkey refers to the corrections made to the document - the date had been changed twice and the original executioner refused to be involved, so names were altered. 

Wednesday, 3 September 2014

Debate centres around Charles' intentions during the settlement period:
By 1648, he knows there will be no settlement and now aims to be a martyr for the monarchy to be resorted in the future
Or
Charles never wanted a settlement (due to his "divine right"). He is the main reason why he is executed. 
Suicide or murder?

Charles after escaping Hampton Court fled to the Isle of Wight and hoped that his relative Colonel Hammond would protect him, then he planned to head to France. Colonel Hammond, however, was loyal to Parliament and turned him in, where he was imprisoned in Carisbrooke Castle. Charles then began corresponding with the Scots and in December 1647, he signed the Solemn League and Covenant in the English Parliament and imposed Presbyterianism for 3 years. He also agreed that Scotsmen would have greater influence in the English government with a view of eventually combining England and Scotland as one Kingdom. In return the Scots would take him to London to negotiate with Parliament, who if refused, the Scots would then send an Army to England to assist Charles. 

Why was the Engagement Significant?

It meant a real possibility of war or Scottish invasion and hardens views towards the King. It lead to the Vote of No Addresses in January 1648, which stated that there would be no further negotiations with Charles. 

Reading - July 16th, 1647


  • The Army's General Council met. Appeared to be signs that the general unity of the army that had held to date was beginning to break down. 
  • The agitators had become more impatient with the slow progress in achieving their demands and were pushing for a more immediate march on London to secure their demands 
  • At Reading, it became more clear that senior officers now had a fundamental design for settlement and were negotiating directly with Charles
  • These negotiations opened Ireton and Cromwel up to charges of hypocrisy. 

Heads of Proposals - August 2nd, 1647

  • Regular biennial parliaments 
  • Reform of parliamentary representation 
  • Parliamentary control of army and navy
  • Parliamentary appointment of great offices of state for 10 years 
  • Religious settlement that maintained national Church with bishops, but no coercive power
  • Act of Oblivion (pardon) that exempted only a few royalists from punishments 

Negotiations with Charles 

  • Their willingness to compromise with Charles brought division in the army to a head and would also be the basis of their own more hard-line attitude to Charles after the 2nd Civil War 
  • The Grandees of the NMA wanted settlement because they wanted a good working relationship with the King, with Berkley commenting that Ireton may able to get the "Heads" through the Army Council. 
  • Ireton modified the "Heads" after talking to the King and there is little doubt that Ireton and Cromwell went as far as they felt they could in trying to get Charles to accept the Heads
  • The tension between the Army and Parliament increased. The Political Presbyterians organised demonstrations in favour of peace on the 26th July, with the convenience of Holles, a mob invaded the Commons and forced the passing of a resolution to invite the King to London. 
  • By 3rd of August, the Army was just outside of London, where the Political Independents joined them after walking out of Parliament. 
  • Charles escaped from Hampton Court on 11th November. In response to the new military threat posed by Charles' escape and his negotiations with the Scots, the NMA officers reunited. An attempted Leveller inspired military in the army at Wore was crushed. 
After Charles' surrender, the New Model Army became increasingly politicised. This was due to their dissatisfaction with the settlements offered to the King by Parliament. They also had material concerns - wages were £3 million in arrears and Parliament had proposed to disband them in the Newcastle Propositions. As Parliament failed to address their concerns, the demands of the army became more radical.

When Parliament proposed to disband the Army, Fairfax ordered a meeting at Newmarket on 4th/5th June 1647. During this meeting a more formal political structure in the army was developed. A General Council was created to allow official strategies and possible settlement to be discussed. The General Council was made up of two officers and two agitators (more radical, pushing for change) from each regiment. This was led by Henry Ireton who had the role of Commissary General.

What were the Heads of Proposals?

The army had so much say during the settlement period because:

Physical control of Charles: 
Charles had been placed under semi-protective house arrest by Parliament after his surrender. He was based at Holmby in Northamptonshire. On 2nd June, 1647, the Army seized Charles from Parliament. George Joyce, a Coronet in the army arrived at Holmby House and said that he had Cromwell's permission to remove the King. Joyce had associations with the agitators. He was allowed to take custody of Charles and immediately took him to the Army's headquarters at Newmarket. Most of the garrison protecting the King went with Joyce. Fairfax was furious but it seemed as though Joyce had the approval of Cromwell and Ireton

The Solemn Engagement:
The first step of the army's demands that had been declared in the Humble Remonstrance were put into action through the documents of the Solemn Engagement which encouraged cooperation between the army's officers and the agitators. This document was mainly drafted by Ireton. In June, Cromwell, Ireton and Fairfax met with Charles and to reinforce the Solemn Engagement, impeachment charges were drawn against 11 MPs, including Holles (Political Presbyterian) - the army saw him as leading Parliament against them.

Humble Remonstrance 
Produced on the 4th June, 1647. The Remonstrance declared that the army would not disband until their grievances were met - i.e. indemnity (no prosecution or punishment for affairs during the First Civil War) and also the removal of the Political Presbyterians who wanted to disband the army.

"A Representation of the Army" 
Drafted on the 14th June, 1647 by Ireton, Lambert and Cromwell. The Representation outlined the army's political position and what they wanted. Main points focused on:

  • Purge of Parliament
  • Future Parliaments of Fixed Duration 
  • Guaranteed right of freedom or people to petition to Parliament (meaning free speech and say)
  • Liberty of tender consciences (religious freedom)


All these influenced what was to be in the Heads of Proposals 

Wednesday, 27 August 2014

There was a Second Civil War for many reasons...

Long term reasons:

  • Fractions with Parliament - between the New Model Army and Royalists - lack of unity
  • Failed settlement after the First Civil War
  • Charles' intransigence - repeatedly vague during genuine efforts of settlement 
  • Solemn League and Covenant - Did Parliament have time to uphold their promise to the Covenanters? 

Short term reasons:

  • The Engagement - the threat of the Scottish army invading Parliament if they do not accept Charles' acceptance of the Solemn League and Covenant. They would march to London, where Parliament was
  • Parliament and the NMA faced a Scottish invasion 
  • Still Royalist support - more than Fairfax had predicted
  • Charles' personality and intransigence. 

July 1646 - Newcastle Propositions: Parliament (Presbyterians) proposed that the armed forces should be controlled by Parliament for 20 years and that only Parliament could disband itself


May 1647 - Solemn Engagement: Army would not disband until they were paid


June 1647 - Declaration of the Army: said "we are not mercenaries" and demanded that anti-army MPs should leave. 11 MPs left as a result.


Summer 1647 - Heads of Proposals: army offered Charles a settlement where the Church would become independent of the State


August 1647 - Putney Debates: the Army debated what their political stance should be amongst themselves


December 1648: Pride's Purge. 


Powered by Blogger.