Struggling to keep up with Charles I, Cromwell and Charles II's antics? Well no need to worry any more as you're in the right place! Here you will find useful notes and simple information to help you succeed in your A2 History (course 3D British Monarchy: The Crisis of State) exam in May! My name is Caitlin Hughes, I received A* at History A-level and currently on a gap year.

Showing posts with label Charles' weaknesses. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Charles' weaknesses. Show all posts

Thursday, 11 September 2014

The Levellers - Who were they and why did they have such influence?

"Wee still find the Nation oppressed with grievances of the same destructive nature as formerly though under other notions." (Leveller Large Petition, March 1647)
The Levellers were a group of people who called for economic, political and religious reform due to the result of economic distress caused by civil war. They were influenced by the ideas of natural law and built an intellectual tradition of dissent. 
  • Natural Law - a law that is set by nature and therefore has validity everywhere above human laws. Associated with natural rights that limited the power of the monarchy. 
The Levellers were led by John Lilburne, Richard Overton and William Walwyn. John Lilburne had suffered persecution in the 1630's by publishing literature against the Armenian reforms of William Laud. 

The Diggers - the "True Levellers"

The Diggers were another response to the political, economic and social effects of the Civil War. They established a commune as a solution to the social inequalities. They were led by Gerrard Winstanely who said "freedom is the man that will turn the world upside down." They believed in total political and social equality. 
Kishlansky argued that the "Digger movement appeared more ominous that it actually was" because the ideas and actions of the movement offered a fundamental challenge to the nature of politics and society at the time, but their influence was limited.

Why did the Levellers deny connections with the Diggers?

Their agenda of "leveling of all debates" - the amendment of private property rights - was too much of a radical step for the Levellers, who were attempting to negotiate a political settlement within the existing social order. 

What were the main aims of the Diggers?

  1. Communal cultivation of the land and end to property rights 
  2. People to support themselves by cultivating the waste and common land of England 
  3. Utopian communistic society

The Putney Debates

The Putney Debates, held in November 1647, were a series of discussions between factions of the New Model Army and the Levellers concerning a new constitution for England. They were held at the Church of St Mart the Virgin, Surrey. 
  • The Grandees failed attempt to negotiate a settlement with Charles had lost the support of the military and civilian radicals. The Levellers criticised Ireton in particular for being too lenient in his negotiations with the King and Parliament, and accused the Grandees of betraying the interests of the common soldiers and people of England. 
  • In October 1647, the 5 of the most radical cavalry regiments elected new Agitators - known as the "New Agents" - to represent their views. The New Agents issued a political manifesto: "The Case of the Armie Truly Stated" and endorsed the constitutional proposals drafted by civilian Levellers in the "Agreement of the People."
  • The radicals wanted a constitution based upon manhood suffrage ("one man, one vote"), biennial parliaments and a re-organisation of parliamentary constituencies. Authority was to be vested in the House of Commons rather than the King and Lords. Certain "native rights" were declared for all Englishmen - freedom of conscience, freedom from imprisonment into the armed forced and equality before the law.
  • Cromwell and Ireton regarded the Levellers' demands for manhood suffrage as "tantamount to anarchy"

The Agreement of the People, 1647

  • MP's should be elected in proportion to the amount of people in their constituencies
  • Parliament should be dissolved on the 30th September 1648
  • Parliaments should be held biennially and sit every other year from April to September
  • A biennial parliament should be the supreme authority in the land, with the powers to make/repeal laws, appoint officials and conduct domestic and foreign policy. 

The Whitehall Debates

  • After the King's defeat in the 2nd Civil War, an extended version of the Agreement of the People was promoted by Lilburne who hoped to find a middle way between royal despotism (or tyrannical absolutism) and military dictatorship. 
  • The new Agreement was discussed by Levellers, London Independents and the Army Council at Whitehall in December 1648 in the aftermath of Pride's Purge. 
  • Lilburne wanted to secure Parliament's acceptance of the Agreement before the King was brought to trial so that the trial would  have a basis in a legitimate and legal constitution. 
  • However, Lilburne and his colleague Richard Overton walked out of the discussions when Army officers, led by Ireton, insisted upon making further modifications to the Agreement before it was presented to Parliament. 

Why was this significant?

Here, both Cromwell and Ireton were trying to curb the extremism of the Levellers, particularly over a proposal that wanted to extend the vote to all adult males. Attempts to get support for the Agreement at a meeting of the Army at Cochbush field were forcibly opposed by the Grandees. Lilburne tried making a midway point between tyrannical anarchy and military dictatorship, but this still was not enough for Cromwell and Ireton. 
In the end, discussions continued without Lilburne's input. The revised Agreement was finally presented to the House of Commons as a basis of a new constitution on 20 January 1648, the very days that the public sessions of the High Court of Justice began. As Ireton had calculated, MP's postponed discussion of the Agreement until after the King's trial, and it was never taken up again by Parliament. 

Wednesday, 27 August 2014

What position was Charles I in after he surrendered in 1646 and why?

At the time of his surrender in 1646, the King still had authority over England and his multiple kingdoms. Although the Parliamentarian forces may have driven him to surrender, Charles was still King of England and therefore upheld all authority over both forces.
Charles had received the throne via the "Divine Right of Kings" and was seen as God's defender of faith. To remove the King would be to some, especially Charles, blasphemy. To commit regicide would be an act against God and therefore a sin - ultimately going against the ideology of the New Model Army. 

This section of the course is a common exam question, for example June 2011 "The main reason for the defeat of the Royalist cause in the First Civil War was the leadership of Charles I." In these notes you will find key themes that would help you answer the 45 marker. 

Administration 

Oxford was the main Royalist stronghold, but it was limited in the range of its authority. Charles' diluted the power that was held in Oxford by opening another Royalist stronghold in Bristol, removing capable men like Hyde. 

Scotland 

Solemn League and Covenant September 1643 - Parliament had an advantage of the Royalists. Parliament had paid £30,000 a month for the Scots' army. At Montrose there were several defeats. This makes it crystal clear that the Covenanters caused masses of trouble for the Royalists. 

Division 

Henrietta Maria (Charles' French wife) and Hyde put forward different ideas. The Queen wanted to the war to continue - this subsequently affected Charles' honour. Hyde, on the other hand, wanted a settlement with Parliament. This and a combination of Charles' lack of leadership and ability lead to weak and incoherent policy. 

Indecisiveness

Charles failed to recognise that he needed to take direct advantages over the Parliamentarians on the battlefield. This was due to his indecisiveness with the gentry and lack of creative resources

Generals 

Charles had roped in "influential men" to gather support but instead, they divided opinion among the Royalist army. Some of Charles' soldiers were not trained properly, especially compared to the power of the New Model Army. The presence of the Princes of the Rhineland caused division 

Charles as Military Leader

Charles had appointed himself as Commander in Chief. He ignored advice from lower ranks and couldn't unite supporters. 

Charles' agreement with Catholics 

September 1643 - Charles signs an agreement with the Irish Catholics. This caused the fear that Charles would use Catholic soldiers against the Parliamentarians. Charles made this mistake again with another peace treaty in 1645. 

Others 

  • June, 1645 - Crushing Royalist defeat at the Battle of Naseby. Effectively ends any real resistance. 
  • May, 1646 - Charles surrenders at the Battle of Newark to the Scots, who then sell him to Parliament. 
  • June, 1646 - Siege of Oxford ends as Oxford fails (which had been a Royalist stronghold) 
"Charles was a poor war leader and was unable to provide strong leadership was the war turned in Parliament's favour." - Cust

Powered by Blogger.